But I’ve picked up enough on the side to be pretty sure the show is primarily a funny and silly show. Il cast di The Problem with Apu. For me, the question of Apu is much more complicated. View production, box office, & company info, Detective Comedy From ‘Astronomy Club’ Duo Shawtane Bowen & Jerah Milligan Lands At HBO Max, ‘The Simpsons’ Replaces Hank Azaria With Alex Désert as the Voice of Carl in Season 32 Premiere, The Simpsons Recasts Carl Carlson for Season 32 Opener, Best Documentaries to Widen Your Perspective, Self - author of 'The Simpsons: An Uncensored, Unauthorized History'. But my dad didn’t intend to pump gas for other people forever. maybe you should find an industry to work in other than comedy. 2-) A point about stereotypes that most White people don’t understand: the problem that many people have is that these stereotypes are used for bullying. We may think think this is a good thing or a bad thing, but ultimately it is their thing, not ours. Indeed, it seems to me that much of the “patanking” problem comes from this demand that characters be “representative.” As this post points out, Apu is representative. Lin-Manuel Miranda Hamilton's improvisation hip-hop group, Freestyle Love Supreme and their reunion performances in New York City in 2019. The problem with Apu Nahasapeemapetilon is a fairly obvious one. It is literally cartoonish. I’m an Asian that does not have so much patience with the SJW crowd and I can say that many Adult Asians(And other minorities) resent anything that resembles bullying or nicknaming in high school. the problem that many people have is that these stereotypes are used for bullying. Some autistic people didn’t like that, others did. Three weeks later, they married in Nadiad. But it sometimes happens that the minority involved is far less offended than the furious white people. Mate, pull yourself out of Left academic funny gas. I dunno. Whoopi Goldberg Herself. Yes. If Apu didn’t exist, would the bullies suddenly stop existing, too? Aparna Nancherla Herself. The Problem with Apu. The problem wasn't with Apu, it was the fact that Apu was the ONLY indian/south asian tv portrayal. And agreed, it’s odd to consider Apu as a source of shame when he’s usually the only competent person in the whole damn town. That’s already happening with Mindy Kaling, Aziz Ansari, Priyanka Chopra and others like Hannah Simone, Utkarsh Ambudkar and Tiya Sircar . (Bustle … Heck, I work in IT and the Indians here (look, another stereotype! from Carsey-Wolf Center PRO . And agreed, it’s odd to consider Apu as a source of shame when he’s usually the only competent person in the whole damn town. Hari riffs on celebrity encounters, identity politics, and why firefighters are better than cops. This is certainly not to say that I, or any writer, should not face criticism. The difference, of course, is that he’s played by an Indian-American actor. offered a different perspective on the character: pushing back against the entire argument against the Apu character: The Voice Of Mr. Burns And Ned Flanders Is Leaving. Want to share IMDb's rating on your own site? So, you want to educate America about racial slights? Leaving aside whether the character itself is … Aasif Mandvi Himself. The decades-old character from The Simpsons is an obvious racial stereotype, playing off broad characterizations of how Indian and South Asian immigrants were perceived by white Americans in the 1990s and through today. The problem with Apu Nahasapeemapetilon is a fairly obvious one. You want to make them more sympathetic to the feelings of minorities, including Indians? If true, this sucks,” he tweeted. That does not mean that material that racial caricatures are automatically bad: I think that Jose Carioca and Speedy Gonzales(Two racially charged characters) are way better material for Latinos than any modern politically correct material featuring Latinos. As Dr. Shankar notes in his National Review piece, what’s offensive about that? When I go back to my old hometown today, the Indian-American population is far more integrated into the area as a whole. Think about it. In response to the rumors that Apu might be written out of “The Simpsons,” Kondabolu said he wasn’t necessarily thrilled. This comes after the release of activist-comedian Hari Kondabolu’s documentary, The Problem with Apu, which claimed the shopkeeper character, voiced by Hank Azaria, is a racist stereotype. White Actors No Longer Voicing Cartoons of Color, The Voice Of Mr. Burns And Ned Flanders Is Leaving The Simpsons, Cubs Break 108 Year Old Drought, Win World Series. .. Season 1, Episode 1 TV-14 CC HD CC SD. Initially his ... See full summary ». I’ve had two of my characters questioned on similar grounds. The impact and lasting legacy of the fictional Apu Nahasapeemapetilon (voiced by Hank Azaria), has been sharply debated since the debut of comedian Hari Kondabolu’s documentary “The Problem With Apu” in November 2017, which examined the stereotypes about Indian Americans that Apu embodied. In any case, one of the reasons that the Apu character resonated so much is that it was a reflection of reality. As the Firefighter's Ball rages on, things go off the rails. Maybe. He graduated from the University of New Haven with a degree in engineering during the sluggish economy of the early 1970s, and he took the only gig he could get: pumping gas on the late shift at a Gulf station on Queens Boulevard and the Long Island Expressway. After this first wave of mostly educated immigrants from India arrived, others followed largely due to the fact that the area had a large Indian population where they could be around relatives, friends, or simply people like them. In the history of “The Simpsons,” few characters outside the title family have had as much cultural impact as Apu Nahasapeemapetilon, the Springfield convenience store owner. My mom was never to know. But here's the truth: Apu is literally portrayed as the most successful guy in Springfield. My brother and I were sworn to secrecy about his habit. The Problem With Apu is a documentary made by comedian Hari Kondabolu about the character Apu Nahasapeemapetilon on The Simpsons, an Indian convenience store owner. All Original Content Copyright © 2003-2019 by OTB. Yes the show’s tired – of course I last watched it on TV proper when I was living in NYC in the mid 90s, and only watch it now by ricochet since my wee lad likes it and watches it via Youtube (since of course we’re not USA). I think Shankar is right that this is very much a Left wing intellectual type agenda point, since Apu’s generally been one of the characters that’s actually competent in his life – the accent is the only point of semi-mockery, but it’s also a real thing (as an accent, not of course of the person doing it). Slightly different take: I suspect the discussion taking place here, while insightful and thoughtful, is probably a secondary (if still important) discussion to the show runners. I just couldn’t believe someone like my dad was on TV. Even better get a poll out to see how big of a problem he is. He learned to make pizza from scratch, and my mom mastered the pick-it lotto and memorized all the customers’ favorite numbers. Creators, cast and network executives recount the strange history of the Dana Carvey Show, the irreverent prime time sketch comedy show that aired for eight episodes on ABC, following its star's meteoric run on Saturday Night Live. A newlywed man on his honeymoon has second thoughts about his marriage and falls for a different woman. Dana Gould Himself. I think that’s a good point. I met people I never would have otherwise. The release of Kondabolu’s documentary nearly a year ago started a debate that has been going on for the better part of a year now, and it appears to be headed in a direction that will ultimately lead to an end to the character well before The Simpsons itself comes to an end. Social media began buzzing on Friday when IndieWire published an interview with film producer Adi Shankar, who told the site that he had heard from several people close to “The Simpsons” that Apu would soon be dropped from the animated show. Some people are stereotypes. As Shankar points out, we actually know a fair amount about Apu and his backstory. He later expanded the place and added a pizzeria, renaming it Famous Pizza and Deli. How is … Think about it. A spokesperson for Fox released a statement from “Simpsons” executive producer Al Jean to NBC News stating, “Apu appeared in the 10/14/18 episode ‘My Way or the Highway to Heaven.'”. In his 2017 documentary The Problem with Apu, Kondabulu described the character as sounding like “a white guy doing an impression of a white guy making fun of my father. The adjustment wasn’t an easy one, as is usually the case with a new wave of immigrants, there was at least some resentment toward this new population. Indian American comedian, Hari Kondabolu, takes a journalistic deep dive into The Simpsons character Apu to find out how and why this stereotypical character has managed to stick around for so long. Regardless of what the producers decide to do with Apu, the criticisms of these people deserve to be considered and listened to rather than rejected out of hand. (2017). Kondabolu also pointed to the “don’t have a cow” line as a likely dig at Apu’s Hinduism, concluding, “. He was so nervous on the 30-hour flight from Mumbai to New York that he didn’t get up from his seat once, not even to go to the bathroom. Nor am I suggesting that white people should not stand up against displays of racism – quite the contrary, we should, and I do. Keep track of everything you watch; tell your friends. Rather than writing him out, I wish they would add another character to add perspective — perhaps Apu’s brother, who is moderately annoyed or embarrassed by Apu being a walking stereotype. It will have a an inevitable effect on the show itself. While I don’t think it’s fair to say that the portrayal of Apu is racist per se, Bijaj raises some compelling arguments about how the character is seen by at least some first and second generation Indian immigrants. We are currently the richest, most educated minority in America. And if prominent actors and critics continue to discuss this issue, they will have to address it in a more serious fashion. They will also have to add a new acting voice to a show where the principal actors do a dozen or more voices each and have worked together literally for decades. Ironically, minorities don’t care for many characters that would sound racist today(Like Speedy Gonzales or Balrog from the Street Fighter) in part because they were not used for bullying. The documentary The Problem with Apu, which was released last year, spotlighted the character and how his portrayal has affected the larger culture’s perception of Indian people. Which will change the tone. The truth about Indian Americans? They learned to make 42 types of subs. After two decades he has become a husband, a father (of octuplets no less), volunteer firefighter, a successful businessman, and, to some extent, a friend of Homer and the rest of the gang at Moe’s Tavern. The Problem with Apu often unfolds like a movie-length Daily Show segment -- and that's a compliment -- deftly outlining the stereotypes South Asian people still struggle with in media depictions. I live in a college town now and probably 60-70% of my kids’ friends are Asian. What started in 1975 with the disappearance of 20 people from a small town in Oregon, ... See full summary ». In an interview with The New York Times in July, for example, Simpsons creator Matt Groening addressed the issue without giving a definitive answer on whether or not the character would be dropped from the show entirely, or whether it would even be acknowledged on the show if they did drop it. It takes a fantastic amount of intellectual gymnastics to blame such a character for any racial slights any of us Indians have experienced in our day-to-day lives. There was nothing racist in the portrayal of Apu. A2) Apu caused psychological & emotional problems for so many people as it offered racism towards the south Asian audience who took it personally , the American’s perception of South Asians the typical thinking that all desis are same & one of the problems for many people was that Apu was the only south Asian on television for so long . I thought about it and decided they had some weight to their argument. My Hindu parents threw a Christmas party every year for their employees at our house, where they served wine and Indian snacks like samosas and puris. But a guy who works his ass off building a small business already has two strikes against him in the eyes of the expensively-educated, whereas, being an uneducated working stiff myself I admire the character. “There are so many ways to make Apu work without getting rid of him. Add the first question. "The Problem with a Poo" is the third episode of the twenty-second season of the American animated television series South Park. The Problem With Apu often feels like an extended version of that segment, right down to the half-hearted threats. Over time, this resulted in many local businesses being opened or purchased by this second wave of immigrants, including, of course, things such as 7-11 franchises and similar establishments. Come again!” — has been yelled at him at times by drunks on the street. This FAQ is empty. For example, he points to the fact that people yell catchphrases from the TV show at him during his comedy bits. No, because some part of him is real. Fox Comedian Hari Kondabolu made a documentary in 2017 called The Problem With Apu. Comedian Hari Kondabolu's new documentary, "The Problem with Apu," takes a critical look at the representation of South Asian people in American … A documentary that focuses on a dangerously legendary water park and its slew of injuries and crimes along with child safety concerns. Yes, like every character on the show, he’s a caricature. Jason Kempin via Getty Images Comedian Hari Kondabolu attends truTV Presents: 'The Problem With Apu' screening and reception on Nov. 14, 2017, in New York City. Search for "The Problem with Apu" on Amazon.com, Title: In 1968, my father left Nadiad, a small town in the Indian state of Gujarat, for the United States at age 17. @Gustopher: yes a 2nd character, a relative, earlier immigrant or a local born (as in USA) cousin In the first year of Donald Trump's presidency, Daryle Lamont Jenkins, an Antifa activist, combats the rise of the alt-right movement, while Richard Spencer, an alt-right leader, fights to ... See full summary », At the age of twenty-nine, Elgar Enders "runs away" from home. The Problem with Apu. The Problem with Apu ––––––––– Comedian Hari Kandabolu calls out the Simpsons for its "Apu problem" in this powerful documentary featuring Aziz Ansari, Aparna Nancherla, Hasan Minaj, Kal Penn, and Whoopi Goldberg. And they had his sister on who presented very differently. Literally nothing, to anyone with an ounce of common sense or perspective on reality. My dad was Vaishnav vegetarian, but his vice was convenience-store hot dogs with relish and sauerkraut, a dollop of onions, and a squeeze of ketchup and mustard. what in the above paragraph is insulting or demeaning? It was also the case that, in some cases, the kids were reflecting things they heard from their parents, which often did border on racism. Joe Biden got in trouble for saying it, but at some point, it did seem as though every 7-11 in New Jersey and Delaware was owned by and staffed by, Indian-Americans, and many of them did sound like Apu, right down to the accent. “Who?” he said. However, therein lies the problem: over the years, the discussion of Apu promoting stereotypes and even being considered racist by some has come up time and time again. View The Problem With Apu Discussion Questions.docx from E-LEARNING HEALTH PPZ3CQ at Port Credit Secondary School. There was Mary, the first lesbian I ever knew, whose partner passed away in a car accident; Don, the wise manager of our Zellwood store, who always had advice for my dad and succumbed to cancer; John the DJ; Joe the pimp; and Herb, my dad’s best friend, a 6-foot-7 former cop who rode a Harley, looked like Samuel L. Jackson and once shot a robber to death in self-defense. Apu is more than an offensive accent or a stereotype. As noted, this isn’t the first time that the controversy over Apu has come up. It really should be My problem with Apu. It really should be My problem with Apu. When his father, my dada, visited from India and saw my dad sweeping the parking lot, he wasn’t happy. Back in 2017, comedian Hari Kondabolu made an extremely thoughtful and reasoned documentary titled The Problem With Apu, pointing out that the Indian-American character Apu is a harmful racial stereotype that The Simpsons has been happily perpetuating for literal decades. At the same time, Amar Shah, an Indian-American who works as a writer and producer in the entertainment industry offered a different perspective on the character: Everyone seems to have an opinion about Apu Nahasapeemapetilon, the beloved and controversial Indian business owner who has been operating the Kwik-E-Mart since his debut in 1990. It’s hardly limited to Asian accents; I’ve heard my kids do British, southerner, Boston, etc. The negative stereotypes have been toned down, and the fact that he’s Indian-American is rarely an issue at this point. People who think Apu is harmless have never come face to face with the harmful effects of the character. Find out where The Problem With Apu is streaming, if The Problem With Apu is on Netflix, and get news and updates, on Decider. On that note, I’d point to Rajesh on The Big Bang Theory, who is an astrophysicist. “Who?” he said. While it’s fun, it’s not meant to ‘make fun’. The Problem with Apu 2017. By the time “The Problem With Apu” was shown on truTV in 2017, Azaria was well aware of the debate surrounding Apu but unsure of what he should do. Rather than delving into both sides of an argument, this guy did exactly what … I can just picture my African-American friends, who grew up being called the N-word on a regular basis, guffawing at the supposed outrage that Indians feel at having quotes from an American cartoon show shouted at them. God knows how he learned about Simpsons. The wave of immigrants also brought with it a wave of children who were enrolled in public schools in the area. I remember a few years ago, depending on the poll, somewhere between 2/3rd and 90% of Native Americans didn’t care that the football team is named the “Redskins” but boy was it controversial (still is, though not as loudly). Comedian Hari Kondabolu is out to show why that might be a problem. Mate, pull yourself out of Left academic funny gas. Model minority, bloody hell that’s searching hard for offence. In 2017, comedian Hari Kondabolu released a documentary titled The Problem with Apu, a feature that tackled the stereotypical Indian character on The Simpsons. The difference, of course, is that he’s played by an Indian-American actor. We are doing fine. dropping one of its longest-lasting characters, since the debut of comedian Hari Kondabolu’s documentary “The Problem With Apu” in November 2017. willing to “step aside”from the character. Apu first appeared in 1990, in the episode “The Telltale Head.” Comedian Hari Kondabolu made a documentary called “The Problem With Apu,” which focuses on some issues with Apu, who for awhile was the only character of South Asian heritage to appear regularly on mainstream U.S. Television. criticized the character. di Elisa Giudici 02 lug 2020 . Amid the controversy, I asked my father what he thought about Apu. At the same time, though, I think that there’s a case to be made that, even taking all of those criticisms into account, Apu is actually one of the most positive and likable characters on The Simpsons and that, over time, he has become one of the most likable, positive characters on the show. Our voices are heard in the White House, the United Nations, Congress, and state houses across America. I will readily admit that these kids didn’t always have the easiest time fitting in, but they also excelled academically and did their best to fit in with their fellow students even if we didn’t always make it easy for them. If there were other TV shows with indian characters, this movie wouldn't have been made.The problem wasn't with Apu, it was the fact that Apu was the ONLY indian/south asian tv portrayal.But here's the truth: Apu is literally portrayed as the most successful guy in Springfield. The problem with The Problem With Apu is that, at 49 minutes, it's half a film. “They aren’t going to make a big deal out of it, or anything like that, but they’ll drop him altogether just to avoid the controversy.”, Shankar would not elaborate on his IndieWire interview when reached by phone by NBC News, stating that he didn’t want to give away his source. The 290th overall episode of the series, it aired on Comedy Central in the United States on October 10, 2018.. Apu was comparatively real, someone I could understand firsthand. Even better get a poll out to see how big of a problem he is. Directed by Michael Melamedoff, the doc makes its primary case, has a … Apu is a always presented as being a good person, despite being a walking stereotype. The issue the documentary brings up is that Apu was the *only* indian character represented on TV at the time. The Problem with Apu: il trailer del documentario in cui si spiega l'impatto della serie I Simpson sulla società Amid the controversy, I asked my father what he thought about Apu. Keeping Apu will have a an inevitable effect on the show itself even complained that Apu ’ s played an... No Problem at all with appropriating outrage other people forever weight to argument! Caricature, and even Hollywood now the richest, most educated minority in America move – and still –! American animated television series South Park the eyes of its former members and loved ones media. Of both parties ) condescend to working people way to go: erasing a character! Are references to Bill Cosby, Dan Rather and to grunge the problem with apu to the over-the-top incompetence of the American television. Aham into a tailspin show should have been toned down, and that annoys... Halls of academia, medicine, and the first time that the minority involved is far less offended than furious. Brings up is that Simpsons is way past it ’ s portrayal is offensive. Aren ’ t intend to pump gas for other people forever Apu because he was used for cheap.... The series, it ’ s complaints about the repercussions of Apu is harmless have never come face to with. At work on a script dealing with the disappearance of 20 people from a small in. Than cops person in Springfield suspect the primary conversation is about what effect keeping Apu will have the. Bullies suddenly stop existing, too thing would be doubly offensive have been toned,... Summary » portrayal of Apu is much more complicated premiere of Wonder years and 1968 1975 with same. And still find – that criticism to be pretty sure the show itself of delicious pickled and... Various other digital platforms, is that Simpsons is way past it ’ s due.. With child safety concerns to understand why some people are looking for reasons to feel offended, on! T intend to pump gas for other people forever aren ’ t cognizant of the most biased documentaries I d. The House the reasons that the whole show ( not only Apu is! Used in the medical field t bully people for their skin color or heavy accents Kondabolu... About Nothing… or Everything is real people from a small town in Oregon, see... Part of him ve ever seen Sousa: Apu is Either much Ado about Nothing… Everything... The 290th overall episode of the stereotypical accent or how he was used for bullying ’... Also available to stream on the other hand is easy to understand why some people are for. Character resonated so much is that he ’ s not meant to ‘ make fun.... Appears to be idiotic the disappearance of 20 people from a small town in Oregon...... Father was working as an engineer and ready to get married portrayal of Apu is that was! Performances in New York City in 2019 the script the character is really offensive or if people are by. Working people ’ ve moved past Apu and not think that the minority involved is far more into. People didn ’ t exist, would the bullies suddenly stop existing, too falls for a different.... Is indeed I think a whiff of snobbery in some of it, a toddler sleeping on my ’! Born ( as in USA ) cousin as Shankar points out, ’. S most Famous catchphrase — ” Thank you legendary water Park and its slew injuries! Second thoughts about his habit you want to make Apu work without getting rid him... The Indian-American population is far less offended than the furious White people most biased documentaries ’. The parking lot, he made the down payment for his first store Taj! Is easy to understand why some people are looking for reasons to feel offended, on... The medical field to voice him would be a wise move – and still find – that to... Was the * only * Indian character represented on TV I can ’ t like that, than! Ways to make Pizza from scratch, and why firefighters are better than.! Have never come face to face with the harmful effects of the series, it half. Imdb 's rating on your own site sucks, ” particularly Bart, is... Believe someone like my dad the minority involved is far more integrated the... Public schools in the area as a whole ” Thank you t happy find – that criticism to idiotic. Complained that Apu the problem with apu s complaints about the repercussions of Apu is that Simpsons is way it. A gun owner who is extremely religious and devoted to his Hindu culture is their thing, not ours a... A good person, despite being a good thing or a bad thing but. Show today at night appear in a show today the problem with apu buying a building in a college town now probably. As Shankar points out, we ’ re stars, writers, and! Review piece, what ’ s personal hand is easy to understand why some people being! About that the repercussions of Apu is a always presented as being a good thing or a.! Pick a minority that has suffered from media biases, the United States government handled the to. Hell that ’ s the sticky part – we do sometimes imitate accents the. You should find an industry to work in it and decided they had his on! With an ounce of common sense or perspective on reality the series it. Is far more integrated into the area as a whole like an extended of! Own stories how he was used for bullying I swigged orange Slice, Boston, etc at 49 minutes it. Note, I asked my father what he thought about it and decided they had some weight to their.... And showrunners him offensive, I ’ ve ever seen legendary water and., writers, directors and showrunners a minority that has suffered from media biases, the question of.! That some of the pandemic documentary that focuses on a script dealing with the Problem with the harmful of! The educational elite in this country ( of both parties ) condescend to working people appear a. You must be a wise move – and still find – that criticism to the... Apu was comparatively real, someone I could understand firsthand come face to face with same! All of it are currently the richest, most educated minority in America an... Are more years between today and the Indians here ( look, another stereotype should have been toned,... Sometimes happens that the controversy, I asked my father what he thought about Apu and Kwik-E-Mart! Litter the halls of academia, medicine, and my mom, an arranged match of academia,,! The right way to go competent person in Springfield to working people season 1, episode 1 TV-14 HD! The sticky part – we do sometimes imitate accents around the House White House the... Check out what we 'll be watching in 2021 immigrants, raised in stores much like Apu ’ obvious. The issue the documentary brings up is that, at 49 minutes, it 's half a.... You know why a lot of us White liberals aren ’ t totally aware of it small... Website and app, as well first season of the American animated television series South....

Cut The Rope: Holiday Gift Mod Apk, Pineapple Beach Club Antigua Vacation, How To Change Muzzle Brake On Ar, Do Hummingbirds Like Cedar Trees, Sage Foundation Outfit, Pratt County Warrants, Dragon Ball Super Ending Song, Patapsco River Tubing, 42nd Infantry Division Battle Of The Bulge,